Why Is Hyeseong Kim Still Benched? Dodgers’ Righty Dilemma and the Rising Korean Star

A Hot Streak Meets a Cold Bench: Kim’s Surprising Exclusion

Did you know? Despite boasting a .372 batting average over 34 games, Hyeseong Kim has once again been left out of the Dodgers’ starting lineup—even when facing right-handed pitchers. On June 25th at Coors Field, the Dodgers fielded their star-studded roster against the Rockies, but Kim’s name was missing. This decision has left fans and analysts puzzled, especially given Kim’s consistent performance and ability to deliver in clutch moments. The move comes as part of manager Dave Roberts’ strict platoon system, but the logic is increasingly being questioned as Kim’s stats outperform several regular starters.

The Platoon System: Strategy or Stubbornness?

Manager Dave Roberts is known for his commitment to the platoon system, where left- and right-handed batters are rotated based on the opposing pitcher’s handedness. However, Kim’s case is unique: he’s been benched not only against lefties but also, surprisingly, against righties like Germán Márquez. This has led to growing criticism, with many pointing out that Kim’s offensive output and defensive versatility should guarantee him more playing time. Korean and international media alike have highlighted that Kim’s .372 average and .948 OPS are far superior to some of his teammates who continue to start despite slumping performances.

Community Reactions: Outrage and Support from Fans

On Korean platforms like Naver, Daum, DC Inside, FM Korea, and PGR21, the sentiment is overwhelmingly negative toward Kim’s benching. Comments such as “How can you bench a .370 hitter?” and “Roberts’ stubbornness is hurting the team” dominate the threads. In contrast, a minority of fans suggest patience, arguing that the Dodgers’ deep roster and playoff ambitions justify cautious management. Internationally, Dodgers fans echo these frustrations, with many calling for Kim to be given a regular starting role, especially as other outfielders and infielders struggle offensively.

Cultural Context: Korean Players and the MLB Adjustment

For international readers, it’s important to understand the unique pressures Korean players face in MLB. Kim, a multi-Golden Glove winner in Korea, arrived in Los Angeles with high expectations and a $12.5 million contract. The Dodgers’ history with Asian players, including Chan Ho Park, Hyun-Jin Ryu, and Shohei Ohtani, means that Kim’s every move is closely watched by both Korean and American media. The strict platoon usage contrasts with his role as an everyday player in the KBO, making his adjustment both a personal and cultural challenge.

Media Spotlight: What the Experts Are Saying

Recent articles from Chosun, OSEN, and DodgerBlue highlight the controversy. Analysts note that Kim’s limited playing time is at odds with his production, especially as he ranks among the top rookies in the National League. Some speculate that Roberts’ reluctance to break from the platoon system may be costing the Dodgers valuable wins. MLB.com and other outlets have listed Kim as a top impact rookie for 2025, underscoring the disconnect between his potential and his current usage.

The Numbers Don’t Lie: Kim Outshines His Competition

Comparisons with other Dodgers bench players are stark. While Kim maintains a .372 average, others like Michael Conforto are hitting just .171. Despite this, Conforto and others continue to receive regular starts. This statistical gap has fueled further debate about fairness and meritocracy in the Dodgers’ lineup decisions. Some fans on American forums have even called for a midseason trade to give Kim more opportunities elsewhere.

The Road Ahead: Will Roberts Change Course?

There are signs that change may be coming. Following mounting criticism, Roberts has hinted at giving Kim more consistent starts, especially as the team looks to maintain momentum heading into the playoff push. However, with the Dodgers’ deep roster and constant pressure to win, nothing is guaranteed. For now, Kim’s journey remains a microcosm of the challenges faced by international stars in MLB: proving themselves not just against opponents, but also within their own dugout.