Is Dropping Mohamed Salah the Right Move? Liverpool's Struggles and Son Heung-min's Contrasting Path

Liverpool's Tactical Dilemma with Mohamed Salah

Liverpool's recent poor run has sparked heated debate about Mohamed Salah's role as a guaranteed starter. After a disappointing 1-2 home loss to Manchester United, where Salah's contributions were notably weak with limited successful dribbles and passes, former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher publicly advocated for Salah's benching, especially in away fixtures. Carragher argued that Salah, despite being a club legend, should not be treated like Virgil van Dijk as a first name on the teamsheet every week, highlighting an ongoing struggle between the need for results and respecting a star player's legacy.

Despite Salah's history of titles and personal accolades, including multiple Premier League Golden Boots, this season he is seen as less effective, with current stats reflecting a dip in form and influence on the pitch. Manager Arne Slot has even reduced Salah's defensive responsibilities to spark his form, but the impact has been limited so far. This tactical shift underlines Liverpool's difficult position as they look to reverse a four-game losing streak.

Fan and Media Reaction to Salah's Form

The reaction among fans and media has been mixed but leaning towards frustration. Some Liverpool supporters still cherish Salah's past contributions, especially following his recent contract extension, hoping this signals a revival. However, a growing segment of fans and pundits criticize his current work rate and effectiveness, as his prolonged goal drought and missed chances in key matches weigh heavily. Media outlets have documented the pressure mounting on Salah as well as the club's internal debate about whether to prioritize immediate results over sentiment.

On social media and football communities like Naver and Tistory, discussions reflect concern but also respect for Salah's legacy, revealing the complex fan culture that oscillates between loyalty and performance demands in high-stakes football.

Son Heung-min's Contrasting Career Trajectory

While Salah grapples with form issues and debates over his starting position, Son Heung-min, the same age as Salah, pursues a very different chapter in his career. After leaving Tottenham following their Europa League triumph, Son moved to MLS's LAFC, where he is flourishing. With impressive stats including nine goals and three assists in just ten matches, Son has become a key player for LAFC, helping his team contend strongly in the league.

Son's success overseas highlights a cultural and professional contrast: choosing a fresh challenge beyond European football and thriving, while Salah faces the pressure cooker of maintaining elite performance at a club in transition. Son's ability to adapt and excel in a new environment makes him a compelling example of career evolution for top players at this stage.

Broader Implications for Liverpool and Player Legacy

Liverpool's handling of Salah's situation symbolizes the challenges clubs face balancing legacy players with tactical needs. The decision to bench or start a player like Salah involves considering not only current form but also team cohesion and fan sentiment. As Liverpool battles fixture congestion and disappointing results, the debate extends to how the club evolves with its aging stars.

Meanwhile, Son Heung-min's trajectory offers a narrative of reinvention and sustained excellence, inspiring fans and players alike. For Liverpool, the focus remains on how to optimize their squad for sustained success, while for Salah, time is of the essence to reclaim his influential role before the twilight of his top-flight career.